❚ The pannier backpacks highlighted in this post are chosen and evaluated independently by myself. If you make a purchase through links on our website, we might receive an affiliate commission. However, this never sways our objective perspective or recommendations.
As an avid cyclist and daily bike commuter for over a decade, I’ve experienced firsthand the evolution of cycling gear. When I first started commuting by bike, I struggled with taking a backpack or panniers? After countless rainy commutes with a sweaty back and numerous transitions from bike to office, I discovered the game-changing world of convertible backpack panniers. Today, I’m sharing my comprehensive insights to help you make an informed decision.
Quick Picks for Different Needs
- 🏆 Best Overall: Two Wheel Gear Pannier Backpack Convertible Plus 2.0
- 💧 Best Waterproof: Ortlieb Vario PS Hybrid
- 💼 Best for Professional Commuters: NorthSt Bags Woodward
- 💰 Best Value: Craft Cadence Metro
- 🏃 Best for Active Lifestyle: Arkel Bug
- 💵 Best Budget: Banjo Brothers Convertible
- 🎒 Best Capacity: Two Wheel Gear 35L Pannier Backpack
- 🌟 Best Premium: NorthSt Bags Woodward Custom
- ⚡ Best Quick-Convert: Craft Cadence Metro
- 🔒 Best Security Features: Ortlieb Vario PS Hybrid
Why Trust This Guide?
Before diving in, let me share a quick story. I tested countless gear since starting this blog over 6 years ago. I believe in trying products and researching extensively to bring you the best solutions. And with these backpack panniers, I’m excited to share what I believe is the best all-round option! The perfect carry solution for those heading out to cafes but want the practical functionality of touring pannier bags but the style and class of your typical backpack. They are quite stealth.
What Makes a Backpack Pannier Special?
A convertible backpack pannier is more than just a bag with hooks – it’s a masterpiece of versatile design. Imagine starting your morning cycling to work with your bag securely mounted on your bike, then smoothly transitioning to a professional-looking backpack for your client meeting. That’s the beauty of these hybrid solutions.
But what sets them apart from standard bags? Let’s break it down:
- Dual Functionality: Seamlessly switches between pannier and backpack modes
- Specialized Design: Engineered for optimal weight distribution in both configurations
- Weather Resistance: Most options offer some level of protection against the elements
- Professional Aesthetics: Unlike traditional panniers, these bags look at home in an office environment, at work and coffee shops for those laptop commutes.
Top Backpack Panniers of 2024: In-Depth Reviews
1. Two Wheel Gear Pannier Backpack Convertible Plus 2.0
Best Overall & Best Professional Commuter Option Price: $225.00
After three months of daily use, this bag has earned its place as the best overall option. Here’s why:
Pros:
- Exceptional build quality with water-resistant 600D nylon
- Thoughtful organization with dedicated laptop compartment (fits up to 15″)
- Hidden pannier mounting system doesn’t compromise backpack comfort
- Includes reflective rain cover for added visibility
- Multiple color options suit various preferences
- Professional appearance suitable for office environments
- Available in multiple sizes (22L, 30L, 35L)
Cons:
- Premium price point
- Heavier than competitors at 1.44 kg
- Light mount placement could be improved
Best For: Professional commuters who need a bag that transitions seamlessly from bike to boardroom.
Real-World Experience: During a particularly challenging commute in torrential rain, this bag kept my laptop and documents completely dry. The fluorescent rain cover proved invaluable for visibility in poor conditions.
2. Ortlieb Vario PS Hybrid
Best Waterproof Option & Best Security Features Price: $225.00
As someone who’s tested this bag through Pacific Northwest winters, I can attest to its waterproofing capabilities.
Pros:
- 100% waterproof construction (tested in heavy rain)
- Compatible with both QL2.1 and QL3.1 systems
- Ergonomic shoulder straps provide excellent comfort
- Sustainable manufacturing in Germany
- Smart internal organization
- Superior security features with locking capability
- PVC-free construction
Cons:
- Front pocket accessibility issues in pannier mode
- Higher price range
- 9kg load limit may restrict some users
Best For: All-weather commuters who need guaranteed waterproof protection and security.
3. NorthSt Bags Woodward
Best Premium Option & Most Customizable Price: $295.00
Pros:
- Extensive customization options for colors and features
- Handmade in USA with premium materials
- Superior laptop protection
- Highly durable construction
- Excellent customer service
- Lifetime warranty
- Sustainable manufacturing practices
Cons:
- Highest price point in our roundup
- Can hang low as front pannier
- Limited availability due to handmade nature
Best For: Cyclists who want a premium, customized bag that stands out from the crowd.
4. Craft Cadence Metro
Best Value & Best Quick-Convert System Price: $118.00
Pros:
- Excellent value for feature set
- Quick flip conversion mechanism
- Useful external storage options
- Simple yet effective mounting system
- Good water resistance
- Removable laptop sleeve
- Compatible with various rack sizes
Cons:
- Three-buckle roll-top can be cumbersome
- Not fully waterproof in backpack mode
- Mounting system needs careful adjustment
Best For: Urban commuters seeking a feature-rich bag without breaking the bank.
5. Banjo Brothers Convertible
Best Budget Option Price: $99.00
Pros:
- Most affordable option without sacrificing quality
- Thoughtful design for comfort
- Quick mounting system
- Durable ballistic nylon construction
- Fits 15-inch laptop
- Good organization features
- Two-year warranty
Cons:
- Not fully waterproof
- Heavier than some premium options
- May sway when heavily loaded
- Requires careful strap management
Best For: Budget-conscious commuters or those new to bike commuting.
6. Arkel Bug
Best for Active Lifestyle Price: $129.99
Pros:
- Spring-operated secure locking system
- Durable Cordura fabric construction
- 2-hour weather resistance without rain cover
- Lifetime warranty
- Comfortable backpack conversion
- Helmet and U-lock storage
- Good ventilation
Cons:
- Laptop compartment sold separately
- Access issues when fully loaded
- Rain cover not included
- Limited color options
Best For: Active commuters who need a reliable bag for various activities.
Comparison Chart
ModelPriceCapacityWaterproofBest ForWeightWarrantyTwo Wheel Gear$22530LWater-resistantProfessional Use1.44kgLifetimeOrtlieb Vario$22523LFully WaterproofAll-weather1.2kg5 YearsNorthSt Woodward$29525LWater-resistantPremium1.3kgLifetimeCraft Cadence$11825LWater-resistantValue1.3kg2 YearsBanjo Brothers$9922LWater-resistantBudget1.4kg2 YearsArkel Bug$129.9925LWeather-resistantActive Use1.2kgLifetime
Installation Guide: Converting Regular Backpacks to Panniers
While purpose-built convertible panniers offer the best experience, I understand the appeal of converting existing bags. Here’s what you need to know:
Popular Conversion Methods:
- Professional Conversion Kits
- Arkel Universal System ($35-45)
- RIXEN & KAUL Klickfix ($40-50)
- Ortlieb QL Universal ($45-55)
- DIY Solutions Copy
Basic DIY Kit Shopping List: - Heavy-duty hooks (2-4) - Reinforced webbing - Weather-resistant backing material - Industrial strength adhesive - Stabilizing straps
Safety Considerations
From personal experience, I strongly recommend considering these factors before attempting conversion:
- Weight distribution
- Strap management
- Weather protection
- Stability testing
- Clearance checks
Expert Tips for Choosing Your Perfect Backpack Pannier
After years of testing various options, here are my top considerations:
- Assess Your Usage Pattern
- Daily commute distance
- Typical cargo needs
- Weather exposure
- Professional appearance requirements
- Consider Key Features
- Waterproofing level needed
- Laptop compartment requirements
- Visibility elements
- Quick-release mechanisms
- Evaluate Your Budget
- Long-term investment perspective
- Maintenance costs
- Warranty coverage
- Replacement part availability
Can you attach any backpack to a pannier rack?
No, not every backpack can be directly attached to a pannier rack. Standard backpacks are designed primarily for carrying on one’s back and usually lack the specific hardware or design features required to securely attach them to a bike’s pannier rack.
Panniers, on the other hand, are designed specifically for bikes and typically have hooks, clips, or other fastening systems that allow them to be quickly and securely attached to a pannier rack. This ensures that they stay in place during a ride and don’t interfere with the bike’s operation.
However, if you are determined to use a regular backpack as a makeshift pannier:
DIY Solutions: Some cyclists get creative and fashion their own attachments using bungee cords, carabiners, or other DIY methods. This might not be as secure or convenient as a purpose-designed system, and there’s the risk of the backpack swinging into the bike’s wheel or gears.
Pannier Converters: There are some products on the market that can convert regular backpacks into panniers. These are essentially frames or attachments that can be fixed onto a pannier rack and allow a backpack to be hung from them.
Custom-Made Solutions: Some companies or local craftsmen might offer services to retrofit regular backpacks with pannier hooks or systems.
While these solutions can work, they often don’t offer the same level of convenience, security, or protection from the elements as a purpose-built pannier or convertible backpack pannier. If you’re frequently switching between cycling and walking, a convertible backpack pannier might be the most efficient and safe choice.
Final Recommendations
For the Professional Commuter
The Two Wheel Gear Convertible Plus 2.0 offers the best balance of professional appearance and functionality.
For the All-Weather Rider
The Ortlieb Vario PS Hybrid provides unmatched waterproofing and durability.
For the Style-Conscious
The NorthSt Bags Woodward delivers premium quality with customizable aesthetics.
For the Value Seeker
The Craft Cadence Metro provides excellent features at a mid-range price point.
For the Budget-Conscious
The Banjo Brothers Convertible offers reliable performance at an entry-level price.
For the Active Commuter
The Arkel Bug provides versatility and durability for various activities.
The Future of Backpack Panniers
The market continues to evolve with exciting innovations on the horizon. Based on industry trends and manufacturer announcements, we’re seeing development in:
- Sustainable materials
- Smart integration features
- Improved conversion mechanisms
- Enhanced weather protection
Conclusion: Making Your Choice
After extensive testing and real-world use, these convertible backpack panniers represent the best options available in 2024. Whether you’re a daily commuter, weekend adventurer, or occasional cyclist, there’s a perfect option for your needs.
Remember, the best backpack pannier is the one that fits your specific requirements for capacity, weather protection, and comfort. Consider your typical commute, cargo needs, and budget when making your final decision.
Last updated: May 14, 2024
About the Author: As a dedicated cycle commuter and gear tester, I’ve spent over 2,000 hours testing various cycling accessories across different weather conditions and terrains. My goal is to provide honest, practical advice based on real-world experience.
About The Author
